Cookie Company
Evansville Catering
Downtown Evansville Store Front
Military Shipping at Domestic Rates



We are closed for the Memorial Day Weekend and will reopen on Wednesday, May 30, at 9am. Have a safe and Happy Memorial Day!

You've never experienced a cookie like a Just Rennie's cookie.

We start by selecting the finest ingredients, like Callebaut imported Belgian chocolate, premium grade AA butter, eggs fresh from the farm, brown sugar, and pure vanilla. Then we pile up the dough and bake it just right to create the moistest, most satisfying cookie you'll ever taste.

Discover our incredibly good cookies:

• Chocolate Chunk • Chocolate Chunk Walnut
• Peanut Butter • Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk
• Double Chocolate Chunk • White Chocolate Pecan
• Oatmeal Raisin • Chef Doug's Gourmet Cookie
• Cranberry Orange • Snickerdoodle
• Cookies & Cream

The following cookies are only available In-Store:

• German Chocolate • White Chocolate Toffee Crunch
• No-Bake Cookies • Peanut Butter No-Bake Cookies

Hours: Monday thru Friday 9am-4pm, Saturday & Sunday: CLOSED


Click for the BBB Business Review of this Caterers in Evansville IN
Gourmet Cookies